Shepherdstown, WV: The Historic Downtown We Almost Missed

We almost missed one of the most charming parts of Shepherdstown, West Virginia.

Mike and I had come to town with our friends to visit O’Hurley’s General Store. After browsing the store and unexpectedly discovering its Thursday-night music jam, we were driving out of town when something caught my attention.

The evening lights were glowing in the shop windows, and the old buildings along the street looked so quaint and inviting. I remember thinking, I’d really like to come back and explore this town.

As it turned out, I had a reason to return the very next day. And it involved a couple of familiar childhood characters.

Historic German Street in Shepherdstown, West Virginia, with colorful storefronts, mature trees, and local shops.
A beautiful afternoon along German Street in historic Shepherdstown, West Virginia.

The Raggedy Ann and Andy Dolls That Brought Me Back

While we were browsing O’Hurley’s, I spotted Raggedy Ann and Andy dolls. I remembered those characters from childhood—the cartoons, the stories, and the familiar faces. I don’t believe I ever owned one myself, but there was something nostalgic about seeing them again.

And now I have a granddaughter of my own.

I left without the dolls that first evening, but I kept thinking about them. By the next day, I knew I wanted to get them for her. So back to O’Hurley’s we went, and this time I bought them.

Raggedy Ann and Andy dolls with bright red yarn hair sitting together among children's books.
These Raggedy Ann and Andy dolls brought me back to O’Hurley’s General Store—a little childhood nostalgia I wanted to share with my granddaughter.

If you haven’t seen my first visit, I wrote about the store and its wonderful Thursday-night music tradition in my O’Hurley’s General Store article. There’s video of the jam session, too.

And since those downtown shops had caught my eye the night before, we made a little room in the day to see more of Shepherdstown. We still had other plans, so this wasn’t a full sightseeing day. We were simply going to enjoy a walk, browse a little, and see what we found.

German Street: A Beautiful Day for a Stroll

German Street is the heart of Shepherdstown’s historic shopping district. With its colorful storefronts, brick buildings, and interesting architectural details, it’s an inviting place to walk.

The day was beautiful. There were plenty of people out, but it never felt crowded. We weren’t bumping into anyone or trying to make our way through a packed street. We could stop at a window, admire a building, or wander into a shop whenever something caught our attention.

I noticed people of different ages and backgrounds enjoying the area. In some of the businesses, customers and merchants seemed to know one another. The shopkeepers we encountered were friendly, and the downtown felt clean, warm, and comfortable—very much like a small town where people still enjoy spending time together.

Shepherdstown Sweet Shop Bakery sign above red patio umbrellas and outdoor seating along a brick sidewalk.

One of our friends had shopped along German Street before but had never visited O’Hurley’s. We’d done the opposite: we had come specifically for O’Hurley’s and almost missed the downtown shops. They’re only a short walk apart, with O’Hurley’s on East Washington Street and the main shopping area on German Street. If you visit, make time for both.

The Shops We Actually Went Into

We weren’t there for a shopping spree, and we didn’t visit every store. But several places were fun simply to browse.

Grapes & Grains Gourmet

110 East German Street

This was such a cute shop. There were wines, gourmet foods, kitchen tools, and all kinds of interesting things arranged in a way that made me want to look at every display.

I even found a decanter I would have bought. Unfortunately, they only had one left, and it was the display item. There wasn’t another available, so I went home without it.

Still, I had a good time browsing. It’s the sort of shop I’d return to when I have more time to look around.

On the Wings of Dreams

139 West German Street

On the Wings of Dreams was a completely different experience. The shop had a peaceful, almost mystical feel, with stones, jewelry, tonics, and other interesting items thoughtfully arranged throughout the space.

I enjoyed simply walking through and looking at everything. I also saw someone having a tarot reading. It was clearly a personal moment, so I continued browsing rather than intruding.

I didn’t purchase anything, but I found the atmosphere relaxing and the shop fascinating. You can find out more about it on the On the Wings of Dreams website.

Dogwood General Store

142 East German Street

We also went into Dogwood General Store. Having just spent time at O’Hurley’s, I thought it was interesting to see how different two general stores could be.

At Dogwood, I remember large bags of dog food, bird feed, soaps, and everyday supplies. It seemed more geared toward practical household and pet needs, while O’Hurley’s had the broad, old-fashioned assortment that had originally drawn me to Shepherdstown.

Both are independent stores, but they offer very different browsing experiences.

Mountaineer Popcorn Company

102 East German Street

We stopped inside Mountaineer Popcorn Company, too. There was quite a selection of flavors, and our friends bought popcorn to take with them.

I was tempted by exactly one flavor: Pretzel Honey Mustard. Unfortunately, they were out of it that day, so I left without buying or tasting any.

Now, I should explain that I’m a little spoiled when it comes to popcorn. Mike makes homemade organic popcorn with organic coconut oil, and I have yet to find one that measures up to his. His has set a pretty high standard in our house!

That means I can’t give Mountaineer Popcorn a taste review from this visit. But if they have Pretzel Honey Mustard the next time I’m in town, I might finally put Mike’s popcorn to the test.

Rock Hill Creamery: Good Ice Cream, One Very Sweet Sundae

111 West German Street

A beautiful day of walking seemed like a good excuse to stop for ice cream, so we went into Rock Hill Creamery. The shop makes its ice cream in small batches rather than using premade mixes.

Mike and I both ordered peanut-butter-cup sundaes. Our friends chose plain ice cream, and they both said theirs was really good.

The ice cream in my sundae was good, too. But between the Reese’s peanut butter cups and all the sweet sauce, it was more sweetness than I wanted. I couldn’t finish it.

If you love a rich, candy-filled sundae, it may be exactly your kind of treat. Next time, I’d order something simpler and let the ice cream itself shine. You can explore the shop at Rock Hill Creamery.

The History Hiding in Plain Sight

I loved the colors and architecture along German Street before I knew much about Shepherdstown’s history. Researching the town afterward made those buildings even more interesting.

Shepherdstown sits along the Potomac River in West Virginia’s Eastern Panhandle. Originally named Mecklenburg, it was chartered in 1762 and shares the distinction of being one of West Virginia’s oldest incorporated towns with Romney, chartered the same day.

McMurran Hall and Its Older-Than-the-Building Clock

One of the buildings that stood out to me was McMurran Hall, with its white columns and clock tower. Built in 1859, it was originally intended as a town hall. But here’s the detail I didn’t know: the clock dates to 1842—older than the building itself. It was moved to the tower in 1860.

Historic McMurran Hall in Shepherdstown, West Virginia, with white columns, green shutters, and a prominent clock tower.
McMurran Hall dates to 1859, but its historic clock is even older, dating back to 1842.

I like finding out things like that after a visit. It gives me another reason to return and notice what I walked past the first time. Historic Shepherdstown has more about McMurran Hall.

The Painted Bench That Stayed With Me

There was one thing along German Street that caught my attention for a completely different reason: a bench painted with a colorful landscape and a message across it.

Colorfully painted sunset bench in Shepherdstown with the words You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough.
Of everything we discovered in Shepherdstown, this bench held a message that stayed with me.

“You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough.”

The artwork was beautiful, but it was those words that made me stop.

I’ve believed that for most of my life. We each get one life, and I want to make the most of mine. That doesn’t mean we all have the same money, opportunities, or ability to take the same trips. We don’t. But I believe there’s still a way to live fully with what we have, while holding on to the bigger things we hope to experience someday.

Some discoveries take planning and saving. Others happen because you notice a little town lit up as you’re driving away and decide to come back the next morning.

That’s part of the heart of Live Thrive Travel: sharing worthwhile places, products, and experiences that help us enjoy more of the life in front of us.

What I’d Go Back to See

Our walk was short. We had other plans, and I left feeling that I’d seen just enough to know I wanted to see more.

We passed Shepherdstown Sweet Shop Bakery, and I’d like to explore that and more of the independent shops on another visit. But one place I especially want to make time for is the Historic Shepherdstown Museum, inside the former Entler Hotel at 129 East German Street. I didn’t get there this time, and learning about the town afterward made me wish I had. Check Historic Shepherdstown for museum hours and visitor information.

I’d also love to return during the Christmas season. Those storefronts were lovely with their evening lights during our fall visit, and I can imagine them dressed for the holidays. I haven’t experienced Christmas in Shepherdstown yet, so I’ll leave that review for another visit.

For 2026, the town lists Handmade Christmas at the War Memorial Building on November 21–22, tree lighting at McMurran Hall on November 27, and a Christmas parade on December 5. Check the official Holidays in Shepherdstown calendar for full details and updates before going.

Planning Your Own Shepherdstown Visit

If you’re thinking about spending time in Shepherdstown, here’s what I’d do differently from our visit:

  • Make a day of it. Our stroll was pleasant, but we had to move on. Leave yourself time to browse, have a meal, and visit the museum if history interests you.
  • Look up the places you care about first. The Experience Shepherdstown website is a useful starting point for shops, dining, and local events.
  • Include both German Street and O’Hurley’s. The general store is at 205 East Washington Street, close to the downtown shopping area but easy to overlook if you came for only one destination. If you want the Thursday-night music jam, check the store’s schedule before going and arrive early for a seat.
  • Plan for walking and parking. We found the downtown stroll comfortable, but it has brick sidewalks and older buildings, and individual entrances vary. The town has metered parking and posted restrictions; check the official Shepherdstown parking information before your visit.

Is Shepherdstown Worth Visiting?

For me, yes. What started with an old-fashioned general store turned into unexpected music, a trip back for Raggedy Ann and Andy dolls for my granddaughter, and a lovely walk through a town we might otherwise have missed.

We didn’t stay long or visit everything. We browsed, enjoyed ice cream, admired the architecture, and spent a little time together on a beautiful day. That was enough to make me want to return.

My advice? Plan ahead, allow more time than we did, and support the small businesses that give Shepherdstown its character. There’s history here, and plenty more to enjoy than you might see on a quick pass through town.

Live well — even here

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top